What is a discrepancy, when does a discrepancy occur and how to resolve it?

Discrepancy is a state of the article which arises when in a two-reviewer project (either 2 humans or 1 human + 1 AI), after the Lead Reviewer resolves a conflict, one of the reviewers later revises their decision.

As a result, both reviewers are now in agreement, but their decision no longer aligns with the Lead Reviewer's decision.

E.g. Reviewer 1 and Reviewer 2 have now decided on EXCLUDE, while the Lead Reviewer's decision remains INCLUDE, or vice versa. 

Conflict                                        Discrepancy

Reviewer 1: Include       →         Reviewer 1: Exclude    

Reviewer 2: Exclude                   Reviewer 2: Exclude

Lead Reviewer: Include              Lead Reviewer: Include

 When a discrepancy occurs:

• All project members will be able to see in the statistics that a discrepancy has occurred.
• The system automatically updates the Statistics and PRISMA numbers to reflect the discrepancy. 

• The affected articles are flagged for easy identification.
• All reviewers involved in article screening will have their quality metrics updated, regardless of their individual role.

Although all reviewers can view that a discrepancy exists, only the Lead Reviewer of that article has the permission to review and resolve it. 

The Lead Reviewer will have access to view all decisions and identify which decision led to a discrepancy. 

Once the Lead Reviewer resolves a discrepancy, the numbers will automatically update in the Statistics and PRISMA. 

• Related Articles

• Who can resolve conflicts?

  In EasySLR, conflicts occur when multiple reviewers assess the same article and make opposing decisions—for example, one includes it while another excludes it. These conflicts typically arise during the Title-Abstract or Full-Text screening stages. ...

• Using the Conflict Filter to Resolve Reviewer Disagreements in EasySLR

  1. What is the Conflict Filter? The Conflict Filter helps you identify articles where your decisions differ from those of the other reviewer at either the Title-Abstract or Full-Text stage. It enables unblinding of decisions, allowing reviewers to ...

• How to Compare AI vs Human Reviewer Decisions in EasySLR?

  EasySLR allows you to assess the accuracy and reliability of its AI-driven screening by directly comparing AI decisions with those made by human reviewers. This validation step helps you understand how closely the AI aligns with your decision-making ...

• Roles and Rights at Project level

  Access Owner Admin Reviewer Lead_Reviewer Guest View Project information ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ View Project Usage data ✓ - - ✓ - View Project Article information ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ - View Project Uploads ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ - Upload Articles for the project ✓ - - ✓ - Upload PDFs ✓ ✓ ✓ ...

• What does re-evaluate all articles in this project means?

  Re-evaluation of the articles allows all articles to be reviewed based on the recent changes. This might be necessary if you need to update the number of reviews required per article. To update the Workflow settings, follow the below steps: Open ...